ERIE, Ill. —
The Erie School Board on Thursday upheld its decision to ban a book and lesson plan on diversity and tolerance of same-sex parents.
In May, the School Board banned the “The Family Book,” by Todd Parr and accompanying materials.
The materials, which are part of the “Ready, Set, Respect!” lesson endorsed by the Gay, Lesbian and Straight Education Network, were implemented at the elementary school this spring as part of the diversity and tolerance unit in the school.
One of the controversial lines in “The Family Book” states “some families have two moms or two dads.” After receiving complaints from several parents, the materials selection committee reviewed the book and lessons before the board voted 5-2 to ban them at its May meeting.
Board member Charles Brown defended the ban and the board’s choice to use other materials for the tolerance and diversity curriculum.
“We have nothing but the students’ best interest in our mind. But we live in a democracy and a vote is a vote. This board voted,” Brown said.
Brown, along with some fellow board members, suggested the community use the school board election in April if they were unsatisfied with the current board.
The ban gained national attention this month after an online petition called for the school board to reverse its decision.
The petition was started by 2010 Erie High School graduate Sean Leeds. Leeds joined a mixed group of more than a 100 book supporters and ban supporters who packed the Erie Middle School cafeteria Thursday.
“It’s crucial to instill tolerance and diversity in our community’s children during a young age...The only agenda here is to promote tolerance in our children,” Leeds said during the meeting. “Exposing children to the reality that is this incredibly diverse world that we live in is not a narrow view, excluding groups from children by trying to protect them from reality is.”
Parent Mindy Jepson on Thursday said she supports the ban because she believes it’s what’s best for her three children at Erie Elementary.
“I don’t feel it’s the school’s job to teach family diversity, gender expressions or any other lifestyles... Parents know their children best and how best to approach these situations. I think 'Ready, Set, Respect!' crosses the line when it starts redefining family, males and females,” Jepson said.
After hearing from several other speakers on both sides of the issue, the School Board had a brief discussion of its previous decision.
Board member Thomas Pons questioned holding referendum on the issue.
“Do we want to be the town that puts that on there and the stigma that’s going to go with it?” Pons asked.
Rather, Pons joined Brown in suggesting the voters hit the polls in April.
Board member Mike Heun agreed and illustrated it is the prerogative of board that will be elected next year and Erie residents to decide whether they want to revisit the issue.
“The final decision, the final word, will be in the hands of the community. This is not the teacher’s school. This is not the administrator’s school. This is the community’s school,” board member Mike Heun said.
After board members stated they would not change their votes, the meeting was adjourned.
“This matter is probably over with until April 2013,” Brown said.
Schools
Related Photos
-
2010 Erie High School graduate Sean Leeds, who started the petition asking the Erie School Board to reverse its ban of "The Family Book" and other teaching materials, spoke Thursday at a special board meeting in the Erie Middle School Cafeteria. Katie Dahlstrom/Clinton Herald
-
More than 100 people gathered Thursday in the Erie Middle School Cafeteria to defend their stance on the Erie School Board's decision to ban "The Family Book." Katie Dahlstrom/Clinton Herald
Discussion
June 15, 2012
Book still banned at Erie
- Schools
-
- Northeast preps for end of grade sharing GOOSE LAKE -- The Northeast School Board is planning to add bus stops next year under the worst-case scenario that a Clinton County District Court judge does not force the Easton Valley School District to honor a whole-grade sharing agreement. North
-
Goose Lake woman teaches in South Korea
A Goose Lake woman will be heading home soon after teaching in South Korea since June 2012.
-
Students prep for prom
Area students will trade the typical jeans and T-shirt this weekend for something a little more formal.
-
Easton Valley responds to lawsuit
In response to the lawsuit filed against it, the Easton Valley School District claims in court documents that the Northeast School District and East Central School District illegally attempted to bind its future actions when they entered into a whole-grade sharing agreement.
-
Going for the grade: CHS, Prince of Peace lauded for students taking AP exams
CLINTON — Clinton High School and Prince of Peace have been recognized as two of the top 25 schools in Iowa for the number of students taking Advanced Placement exams.
- Sophomore coach is reinstated FULTON, Ill. -- It took 4 1/2 hours in closed session, but Jeff Hoese eventually earned reinstatement to two positions within the River Bend School District. River Bend School Board members deliberated from 6:30 to 11 p.m. Monday regarding personnel
- District to study altering school year CLINTON -- Clinton School District students could arrive for their first day of school in 2015 to find shorter breaks spread more evenly throughout the school year. The Clinton School Board agreed during its meeting Monday to form an ad-hoc committ
- Keeping watch: School district leaders hear safety report CLINTON -- The Clinton School Board on Monday learned what the district does to provide a safe environment for all students, staff and community members. Bluff Elementary School principal Mark Bloom, school resource officer Matt Lorenzen and Clinto
- Clinton aims for 100% ACT participation rate CLINTON — Standardized tests make Sara Nickles uneasy, but the Clinton High School junior plans to go into elementary education. Meaning like it or not, standardized tests — such as the ACT — won't disappear from her list of things to do anytime soon
- New school district sends letter to East Central in preparation for next year PRESTON -- The Easton Valley School Board agreed to send a letter to the East Central School Board and superintendent asking for permission to enter the Miles and Sabula School buildings on or before June 1. In order to prepare for the inaugural sch
- More Schools Headlines
